Surveys of over 3,500 National Education Union members working in the independent sector show significant concerns over pay, pension, workload and accessibility to flexible working.
Key findings of the survey of teacher members:
- Almost three quarters of teachers (73 per cent) told us their pay is less than they would expect given their role, responsibilities and workload. 25 per cent received no cost-of-living pay rise in 2025/26.
- Half of teacher members responding to our survey (49 per cent) told us that the pupil: teacher ratio has increased this year at their school.
- Two fifths (40 per cent) of teachers say their employer does not offer the Teachers' Pension Scheme, and this rises to 69 per cent in independent-sector special schools.
Key findings of the survey of support staff members:
- Almost four in five support staff respondents (78 per cent) told us their pay is less than they would expect for their role. 22 per cent stated they had received no cost-of-living increase for 2025/26
- A majority (61 per cent) told us they were not confident of a good standard of living in retirement, based on their current workplace pension. Just 7 per cent were confident.
- Seven in ten support staff (71 per cent) regularly work beyond their contracted hours. Of those who work extra hours, 61 per cent are never compensated.
- A quarter of support staff (25 per cent) say colleagues have left because of poor access to flexible working, and 13 per cent – one in eight - have considered leaving themselves because of this problem.
Pay
Teachers have told us that there is a mismatch between current pay and what might reasonably be expected for the work they do - in terms of role, responsibilities and workload.
Overall, 73 per cent of teachers believe their pay is "less" or "significantly less" than it should be. Teachers in the north and south-west feel this most acutely (79 and 80 per cent respectively).
Across all teacher respondents, 25 per cent told us they received no cost-of-living pay increase for 2025/26. This rose to 31 per cent for those working in schools that are both day and boarding. The average reported increase, where it was received, was 2.7 per cent.
We asked support staff members the same question:
The sentiment was even stronger here with 78 per cent telling us their pay was "less" or "significantly less" than what would be expected. This rose to 87 per cent in special schools in the independent sector, and 86 per cent amongst teaching and learning support assistants (TA/LSA).
Among support staff, 22 per cent told us they received no cost-of-living pay increase for 2025/26. This despite it affecting the standard of living for almost all who responded (94 per cent).
Pensions
The status of the Teachers' Pension Scheme has been undermined in recent years by independent school employers keen to move away from it. Seventy per cent of teacher respondents who are or have been in the TPS tell us that their employer has consulted on leaving the scheme since 2019.
Just one fifth of teacher respondents (20 per cent) work in a school where TPS is available to new staff. 40 per cent tell us their school does not offer TPS at all. This rises to 69 per cent among those working in special schools within the independent sector.
The NEU believes it is a valuable benefit that should remain, and there is a good opportunity now for independent sector employers to return to the TPS with the forthcoming 11 per cent employers' reduction from 1 April 2027.
Support staff were asked in their own survey if they were confident that their current workplace pension - which differs from TPS - will provide a good standard of living in their retirement.
Just 7 per cent were confident of a good standard of living in retirement, contrasting with 61 per cent who were either "unconfident" or "extremely unconfident". This latter stat is far higher than teachers in the sector (41 per cent), and higher still among women support staff (65 per cent net) and TA/LSAs (67 per cent net).
Workload
We asked teachers in independent schools whether their ratio of pupil to teaching staff has changed since a year ago.
There is particular pressure for teachers at boarding schools where two thirds (66 per cent) tell us there are now more pupils per teacher. Overall half of teachers (49 per cent) are affected in the same way.
We followed up by asking teachers if their workload was manageable. Leadership members were more likely to say it was "never" manageable, charting at 24 per cent compared to 16 per cent for teachers overall. Combined with responses that it was manageable only "some of the time", this rose to 68 per cent and 57 per cent respectively.
Turning to support staff, we asked those members working in independent schools how many hours over their contracted hours they would regularly work per week.
Almost one in three (32 per cent) work four or more extra hours per week. In a supplementary question it was made clear that 61 per cent of support staff who work extra hours are never paid or otherwise compensated for those additional hours, which are not only frequent but build up over the course of an academic year to a significant number of unpaid hours.
Flexible working is a concern for many, with 25 per cent of support staff saying they have witnessed staff leave due to its unavailability. A further 13 per cent have considered leaving themselves for this reason.
Commenting on the findings, Daniel Kebede, general secretary of the National Education Union, said:
"Staff in the independent sector have had a torrid few years, with frequent and ongoing attacks on their pensions and job security. There is a clear issue with workload as the pupil: teacher ratio has increased this year, and the mood is not helped by regular unpaid hours for support staff. It is yet more salt in the wound.
“The message from the NEU is clear. Employers within the independent sector need to start valuing their greatest asset - their staff – a good deal more and pay them appropriately for the difficult and responsible jobs they do. Suppressing wages and increasing workloads is not the answer, nor is it acceptable.
“We call on employers to look at workload now for both teaching and support staff, embrace flexible working requests, review pay levels and pension provisions. If an employer is no longer in the TPS or is in phased withdrawal they should consult with NEU reps and staff about possibly returning in full to take advantage of the forthcoming reduction in employers’ contributions and helping to provide financial security for retirement. The data from these surveys should be a wake-up call for employers in the independent sector. Act now and make real meaningful change.”
Editor’s Note
The survey was conducted online by the NEU between 17 September and 6 October. 2,838 responses were received from teacher members and 745 from support staff members. These were weighted by sex, age, region, phase, mainstream or special school, working pattern and boarding status, and teacher responses also by leadership role.