NEU comment on the Alan Milburn report

Published:

Commenting on the independent report by Alan Milburn into proposals for a major overhaul of support for young people,  Daniel Kebede, general secretary of the National Education Union, said:

"Successive governments have failed young people with the deepest school funding cuts in 40 years, an exam factory system and insecure, low-paid jobs.

"Alan Milburn is right that our exam-heavy system fails a third of pupils, drives many to disengage and squeezes out creativity and problem-solving skills employers value. We welcome fewer, less intense GCSE exams and freeing 10 per cent of key stage 3 from the national curriculum.

"But Milburn’s prescriptions for schools contradict his diagnosis, with more tests and targets: a statutory key stage 3 check on top of the Year 8 reading test, and a ready-for-work rate and destination measure for Ofsted to inspect. These would completely contradict Lucy Powell's pledge to stop 'early exam factories', and the NEU opposes them. Whatever Milburn intends, statutory tests become high stakes: schools chase the metric, not learning, and more pupils disengage.

"Schools cannot be held to account for poverty or inequality; ending them is the government's job. If schools must provide work experience by law, large employers should have to offer placements.

"We welcome his call for investment in sixth forms and colleges, cut even harder than schools since 2010, so technical education can stand equal with academic.

"His plan would put £2.1 billion a year into education by 2036, but almost none would reach schools. Young people with SEND are far more likely to become NEET, yet inclusion plans are underfunded. Schools are running on empty, £4.5 billion a year below 2010 spending power, with Europe's largest primary classes. We welcome early years investment and early intervention, but a 90 per cent school-ready target is unhelpful and fails to address the fact that the poorest children miss out on the extra hours of early education and care that working families get.

"His sums rely on £3.6 billion a year of benefit savings. Young people need positive structural reform, not coercion. The NEU will oppose cuts to their benefits, especially for disabled young people. Britain is not poor; its wealth is unfairly shared.

""Young people are not the problem. They have faced austerity at home and at school, lost learning to Covid with no proper recovery funding from the Conservatives and seen council youth services cut by three quarters. Social media giants feed them hate for profit, and AI will reshape the jobs they enter. Without a broad and balanced curriculum and a long-term funding settlement for schools and colleges, no reform will end their disengagement."

 

Back to top